Food manufacturers are paying a high price for Ottawa’s trade war

They’ve become collateral damage in Ottawa’s fight with Washington

Prime Minister Mark Carney’s U.S. trade strategy is starting to crack. And it is Canadian manufacturers who are paying the price for his counter-tariffs.

A chocolate bar made in Mississauga offers a lesson in the economics of the trade war. ZoRaw says Ottawa’s 50 per cent counter-tariff on a key U.S. ingredient has made its protein bars more expensive to produce. The company says it has kept retail prices steady so far. For now, the cost is showing up in its margins.

The ingredient is whey protein isolate, a concentrated milk protein that helps deliver 12 grams of protein per bar. ZoRaw developed its recipe around a specific grade it buys from a single U.S. supplier. A 50 per cent surtax adds $50 for every $100 in customs value before any relief. The duty applies to one ingredient, so it raises the cost of making the whole bar by a smaller percentage. Every dollar ZoRaw absorbs leaves it with less to spend on hiring, product development or expansion.

Why doesn’t ZoRaw buy its whey in Canada? Canadian cheesemakers produce whey, and processors such as Saputo turn it into ingredients such as protein concentrate. Whey protein isolate requires further processing. Agropur, a Canadian dairy co-operative, makes isolate at plants in Idaho and Minnesota. Canadian production data don’t track isolate separately, and it’s unclear whether a Canadian plant can supply the grade ZoRaw needs in the quantities it requires.

Even two isolates with the same protein content can behave differently in a recipe. ZoRaw would have to test whether another grade mixes properly and preserves the taste and texture of its chocolate. Ottawa offers tariff relief for some grades, depending on the specifications. In the meantime, ZoRaw says it is locking in supply agreements and buying some ingredients ahead of expected price increases. Buying early ties up cash.

The United States matters to ZoRaw as a market, too. The company says tariff uncertainty is complicating talks with prospective American retailers. It’s harder to commit to a launch when you can’t say with confidence what it will cost to get your bars onto U.S. shelves.

That exposure on both sides of the border is common in Canada’s food economy. Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada says the U.S. bought about $61 of every $100 Canada exported in agri-food and seafood products in 2025, and food exports are actually on pace to increase in 2026. Canada also bought $38.8 billion in those products from the U.S., and 2026 numbers remain strong. Some of those imports go into foods made in Canada and sold here and abroad. Taxing those ingredients can make Canadian manufacturers less competitive in both markets.

Ottawa is right to seek new customers and suppliers overseas. More options give companies room to manoeuvre when prices rise or governments change the rules. It still takes time to turn a trade agreement into purchase orders. An American retailer a day’s drive from a Canadian plant can offer lower freight costs, faster delivery and easier restocking. Those advantages will still matter after the next trade deal is signed.

Canada had roughly 46,000 fewer people employed in October than in December 2025, on a seasonally adjusted basis. In that labour market, Ottawa should be especially careful about raising the cost of producing in Canada. Before putting a counter-tariff on a food ingredient, it should ask how quickly manufacturers can find a substitute, what the duty will do to their ability to compete and what concession it expects to win from Washington.

If a Mississauga chocolate maker is paying more to make its bars in Canada, Ottawa should be able to say what Canada is getting in return.

Dr. Sylvain Charlebois is senior director of the Agri-Food Analytics Lab at Dalhousie University, co-host of The Food Professor Podcast and visiting scholar at McGill University.

Explore more on Trade, Protectionism, Food industry, Carney government, Agri-food


The views, opinions, and positions expressed by our columnists and contributors are solely their own and do not necessarily reflect those of our publication.

© Troy Media

Troy Media empowers Canadian community news outlets by providing independent, insightful analysis and commentary. Our mission is to support local media in helping Canadians stay informed and engaged by delivering reliable content that strengthens community connections and deepens understanding across the country.

Hussar Voice, a Troy Media Partner

Independent journalism, free to read and use.

Daily commentary and analysis from Canada's trusted editorial network, Troy Media. All content is free to use, but you need a Troy Media account to download.

Register for free access Log in to your account

Trending News

Join the Discussion

We’d love to hear your thoughts. Become a free member to join our discussion threads. Troy Media welcomes civil, relevant discussion. Commenting is a privilege, not a right. All comments are subject to moderation.

By submitting a comment, you agree to our rules and policies.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

By commenting, you agree that:

  • Anonymous or false identities are not permitted
  • Personal attacks, defamation, hate speech, threats, spam, or off-topic posts will be removed
  • Comments must address the article, not other commenters
  • Moderation decisions are final

Troy Media may remove comments or close commenting at any time. If you want debate, argue ideas. If you want chaos, comment elsewhere.

Secret Link